What were they thinking?

At AfterElton.com, gay men (I'm assuming a small group of them and not every one in the country) have countered the People Magazine's 100 Most Beautiful with a list of their own.
I applaud their completely denying a spot on the list to that psychotic mono-brow, Tom Cruise. But I wonder why George Clooney didn't make the list. He kinda twangs the gay-dar a little bit, doesn't he?

#2 Chris Evans: YUM!

Oh, and Justin Timberlake??? EWwwwwwwww!